The Carrot Project

This is number one on our priorities list. Most of it is live on the dev server, in fact. I’ll let you know when it’s live, and you can take it for a spin.

The subscription settings are great!

A suggestion:

I should be able to subscribe to threads that I haven’t commented on. (The reason I want to do this right now is that I’d like to be subscribed to the threads that I commented on before the subscription feature, but I think I should be able to do that for any thread anyway.)

Still waiting on the ubiquitous RSS feeds. ;)

Actually, you have the ability to subscribe to any thread; it’s just that the UI for it is currently a bit on the subtle side :-) Just click on the star icon up to the left of the page title. In addition to comment threads, this allows you to subscribe to anything new in a product category, and to new feedback (on the feedback list page).

RSS feeds are definitely high on the priority list.